Data Analytics report
True fans: 50 customer-cohort cases
Fifty sourced comparisons for HIRO’s true-fan thesis, with conceptual foundations and practical limits.
Research for HIRO’s website and offer · October 19, 2026
Executive Summary
The pattern holds across multiple industries: customer value is uneven. The collection contains direct spending-concentration findings, higher purchasing among engaged customer groups, and separate evidence about referrals and community contribution.
The strongest website argument uses those outcomes precisely. Some small groups account for most spending; others account for a large share, buy more often or contribute more. The evidence supports “your most committed customers can be disproportionately valuable.” It does not establish that a minority of hyperfans generates most revenue in every business.
There are 50 cases here, drawn from 48 source URLs. Related metrics are grouped; three media populations come from one Fandom/comScore study. Kelly and Li Jin provide the conceptual foundation outside that count.
A small customer group can drive most purchasing
At eBay, 19 million enthusiast buyers out of 147 million buyers accounted for 71%Source: eBay of merchandise value. The chart compares their share of the buyer base with their share of merchandise value. This is a clear example of concentrated customer value; merchandise value is not eBay’s own revenue. eBay Investor Day
Manual transcription of eBay’s published 19m enthusiast buyers, 147m total buyers and 71% GMV share. SQLite calculates the buyer ratio; no access to an eBay customer database.
Manual transcription of eBay’s published 19m enthusiast buyers, 147m total buyers and 71% GMV share. SQLite calculates the buyer ratio; no access to an eBay customer database.
| Measure | Share | Definition |
|---|---|---|
| Share of buyers | 12.9% | 19m enthusiast buyers / 147m buyers |
| Share of merchandise value | 71% | 71% of GMV, as disclosed |
True fans need a direct relationship and a valuable offer
Kevin Kelly’s model connects repeat purchases across a creator’s work with a direct customer relationship. His illustrative economics are 1,000Source: Kevin Kelly: 1,000 True Fans fans producing $100Source: Kevin Kelly: 1,000 True Fans of annual profit each. The number changes with costs, income needs and what each fan buys. 1,000 True Fans
Conceptual essay, originally 2008; current page contains an updated version and links the original. An illustrative business model, not an empirical concentration study.
Li Jin explores a higher-value tier: 100Source: Li Jin / a16z: 1,000 True Fans? Try 100 fans each spending $1,000Source: Li Jin / a16z: 1,000 True Fans? Try 100 annually. More value per fan requires a stronger offer, such as access, community, recognition or a useful outcome. Her point makes the product and paid experience part of the strategy. 1,000 True Fans? Try 100
February 6, 2020 conceptual essay. Higher value per fan through differentiated paid offers, community, access and outcomes; not a general measured spending distribution.
For HIRO: identify the people most likely to care deeply, build content around their specific interests, and connect each channel to something worth buying, joining or returning to. AI can support research, production and learning across channels. A real batch with output quality, time, cost and customer response is the evidence needed to show that system scales.
The 50 cases
Each entry states the customer group, measured outcome and period. “Top spender,” “loyalty member” and “superfan” retain their source meanings. Revenue, merchandise value, purchase units, survey responses and contribution are kept distinct.
Music and live events: fandom links spending and participation
These cases come closest to the true-fan proposition: deeper engagement accompanies ticket spending, repeat attendance and sharing.
1Source: Spotify for Artists: Super Listeners. Spotify
Super listeners average 2%Source: Spotify for Artists: Super Listeners of an artist's monthly listeners, account for 50%Source: Spotify for Artists: Super Listeners of ticket sales through Spotify and are 9 times as likely to share music as other listeners.
Spotify super listeners compared with other monthly listeners; platform-defined engagement segments. Spotify publication, July 2025.
Ticket sales through Spotify only. Artist totals, observation dates and sample sizes are undisclosed. Source
Spotify analysis of listening, ticket sales and sharing; averages across artists.
2Source: Nielsen: Turn It Up. US music consumers
Music fans were 40%Source: Nielsen: Turn It Up of consumers and accounted for 75%Source: Nielsen: Turn It Up of music spending. The most committed 14%Source: Nielsen: Turn It Up accounted for 34%Source: Nielsen: Turn It Up.
Nielsen's aficionado, digital and big-box music fans versus other consumer segments. 2013 Music 360Source: Nielsen: Turn It Up / April 2013 consumer report.
Historical category spending, not individual artists' revenue. Both concentration measures come from one study. Source
Consumer survey segmentation, including a 1,000-person US ePanel and separate PledgeMusic and SXSW samples.
3Source: Luminate: Why Are Super Fans So Valuable?. US music superfans
Superfans reported 80%Source: Luminate: Why Are Super Fans So Valuable? more monthly spending on music activities than the average US music listener, and were 43%Source: Luminate: Why Are Super Fans So Valuable? more likely to enjoy participating in artist fandoms.
US listeners aged 13Source: Luminate: Why Are Super Fans So Valuable?+ reporting engagement with favorite artists in at least five ways. 2023 Midyear Music Report; August 8, 2023 article.
Self-reported spending and attitudes. Purchasing partly defines the cohort; the comparison does not establish a content effect. Source
Luminate consumer survey; 19% of US music listeners met its superfan definition.
4Source: Eventbrite/MusicWatch; issuer release reproduced by National Outdoor Events Association; primary Eventbrite North American analysis. UK music festivals | Eventbrite
In the UK sample, 28%Source: Eventbrite/MusicWatch; issuer release reproduced by National Outdoor Events Association; primary Eventbrite North American analysis of festival attendees accounted for 56%Source: Eventbrite/MusicWatch; issuer release reproduced by National Outdoor Events Association; primary Eventbrite North American analysis of annual festival-ticket spending.
504Source: Eventbrite/MusicWatch; issuer release reproduced by National Outdoor Events Association; primary Eventbrite North American analysis UK adults aged 18-49 who had attended a UK festival in the previous year. June 17–28Source: Eventbrite/MusicWatch; issuer release reproduced by National Outdoor Events Association; primary Eventbrite North American analysis, 2016 research; UK release August 8, 2016.
Self-reported clusters partly defined by purchasing. The linked North American sample supports the same study family, not an independent case. Source
Survey clustering based on spending, attendance frequency, influence and repeat attendance.
5Source: The Broadway League, The Demographics of the Broadway Audience 2018–2019. Broadway audiences
The 5%Source: The Broadway League, The Demographics of the Broadway Audience 2018–2019 of theatregoers attending at least 15Source: The Broadway League, The Demographics of the Broadway Audience 2018–2019 performances accounted for 28%Source: The Broadway League, The Demographics of the Broadway Audience 2018–2019 of tickets, or 4.15 million admissions, in the 2018-19 season.
8,972Source: The Broadway League, The Demographics of the Broadway Audience 2018–2019 questionnaires returned across 49 Broadway productions and 98Source: The Broadway League, The Demographics of the Broadway Audience 2018–2019 performance times. 2018–19Source: The Broadway League, The Demographics of the Broadway Audience 2018–2019 season; published January 13, 2020.
Tickets and admissions, not revenue. Attendance frequency defines the high-frequency cohort. Source
Audience survey weighted to paid attendance; 17,400 questionnaires distributed with a 52% return rate.
Games: a small payer cohort can fund most purchases
The spending cases concern paying customers, in-app purchases or top-ups. Steam separately measures concentrated playtime. Neither outcome establishes that the same people lead guilds.
6Source: kongregate-2015. Kongregate
Buyers spending $500Source: kongregate-2015+ lifetime were 4%Source: kongregate-2015 of buyers and generated 72%Source: kongregate-2015 of virtual-goods revenue; 54%Source: kongregate-2015 spending under $10Source: kongregate-2015 generated 1%Source: kongregate-2015. An unnamed game's biggest spenders logged about 20Source: kongregate-2015 sessions/day, 3-4 times active nonspenders.
Kongregate virtual-goods buyers; 2.1%Source: kongregate-2015 of active accounts bought over six years. Virtual goods represented 75%Source: kongregate-2015 of platform revenue. Six years before GDC 2015; some game comparisons use 2014..
Revenue shares concern virtual goods only. The session finding comes from one unnamed game and groups users by eventual spending. Source
First-party platform purchase analysis and an anonymized game's session comparison, presented at GDC 2015.
7Source: gala-2021. Gala Technology | sports games
The top 1%Source: gala-2021 of paying users generated 71.5%Source: gala-2021 of top-ups in 2021; the top 5%Source: gala-2021 generated 90.3%Source: gala-2021. In H1 2022, the top 1%Source: gala-2021 generated 64.7%Source: gala-2021.
Paying users ranked by top-ups; the top 1%Source: gala-2021 numbered 7,228Source: gala-2021 in 2021 and 4,311Source: gala-2021 in H1 2022. 2021 and first six months of 2022; December 2022 IPO prospectus..
Top-ups are not recognized revenue; paying users are not all users. The company also identifies this concentration as a risk. Source
Company payment records and percentile tables disclosed in its December 2022 IPO prospectus.
8Source: appsflyer-2024. Android games | AppsFlyer
The top 5%Source: appsflyer-2024 of paying Android users generated 45.95%Source: appsflyer-2024 of in-app purchase revenue, averaged across apps.
Paying users ranked within each app; the resulting app-level shares were averaged. Q4 chart in January 2023-June 2024 study; Q4 2023 inferred from window..
Paying users, not all players. The chart subset is unspecified; the average is not dollar-weighted and excludes advertising revenue. Source
Anonymized provider analytics; the overall report covers 15,000 gaming apps meeting its monthly acquisition threshold.
9Source: swrve-2016. Mobile games | Swrve sample
The top 10%Source: swrve-2016 of monthly payers generated 48.4%Source: swrve-2016 of in-app purchase revenue. Payers were 1.9%Source: swrve-2016 of active players, making that top group 0.19%Source: swrve-2016 of players.
February 2016 active players in sampled mobile games, with payers ranked into deciles. February 2016..
One month of historical purchases, excluding advertising. Exact game selection and weighting are incompletely disclosed. Source
Aggregated transaction analytics from Swrve clients; the report describes tens of millions of users and fraud filtering.
10Source: applifier-2014. Mobile gamers | Applifier
Heavy payers reported more invitations, gameplay sharing, forum participation and tip-sharing. Players gaming 10Source: applifier-2014+ hours weekly spent $15.15 monthly, versus $2.55Source: applifier-2014 among those playing 1-4 hours.
3,000 mobile gamers recruited via Mechanical Turk; heavy payers spent $10Source: applifier-2014+ monthly. February 2014; GDC 2014..
Historical convenience sample. Sharing differences lack exact chart labels; associations do not establish causality or guild leadership. Source
Survey cross-tabulation of self-reported spending, gaming hours and social behavior, presented at GDC 2014.
11Source: Fandom/comScore, The Power of the Fan, issuer press release. Gaming fans | Fandom/comScore
Heavy gaming fans spent 230%Source: Fandom/comScore, The Power of the Fan, issuer press release more on gaming than light fans and were 3.5 times as likely to buy a game during release week.
Heavy gamers played 15Source: Fandom/comScore, The Power of the Fan, issuer press release+ hours weekly; subgroup sizes were undisclosed. 2017 publication.
Observational comparison; subgroup sizes undisclosed. Same Fandom/comScore study. Source
Shared survey of 5,000+ people and separate 250,000-person behavioral panel.
12Source: steam-2013. Steam players
The top 20%Source: steam-2013 of accounts by playtime accounted for 82.4%Source: steam-2013 of recorded cumulative playtime.
Registered Steam accounts ranked by recorded cumulative playtime. Ownership/playtime May-November 2013; prices April 2014; IMC 2016 publication..
Playtime may include idle games and is not spending. A separate ranking held 73%Source: steam-2013 of estimated library value; that estimate is not actual purchases. Source
Researchers enumerated accounts through the public Steam API and analyzed recorded cumulative playtime.
Retail and collectibles: enthusiasts buy more and return more often
Company disclosures show concentrated purchases and higher value among repeat or premium customers. Membership and wealth are possible explanations alongside emotional attachment.
13Source: eBay. eBay
Enthusiast buyers were roughly 13%Source: eBay of eBay buyers and generated 71%Source: eBay of gross merchandise volume.
19 million enthusiast buyers within a base of 147 million buyers. Year-end 2021 buyer data, presented at Investor Day in March 2022.
Gross merchandise volume is not eBay revenue. Historical, company-defined enthusiasts are not necessarily advocates. Source
Manual transcription of eBay’s published 19m enthusiast buyers, 147m total buyers and 71% GMV share. SQLite calculates the buyer ratio; no access to an eBay customer database.
14Source: Etsy. Etsy
Habitual buyers were approximately 7%Source: Etsy of active buyers and generated about 40%Source: Etsy of marketplace gross merchandise sales in 2025.
Buyers spending $200Source: Etsy+ and purchasing on at least six days in the preceding 12 months. 2025.
Gross merchandise sales are not Etsy revenue. Spending and frequency define the cohort; advocacy is unmeasured. Source
Company transaction records segmented by spending and purchase frequency, disclosed in its 2025 annual report.
15Source: Mytheresa source. Mytheresa
Mytheresa's Top Customer group represented approximately 3.8%Source: Mytheresa source of customers and generated approximately 42.6%Source: Mytheresa source of gross merchandise value in FY2025.
Mytheresa customers and merchandise value, excluding the other LuxExperience segments. Fiscal year ended June 30, 2025.
Gross merchandise value is not revenue or profit. Spending concentration does not establish advocacy or fandom. Source
Company customer-program and merchandise-value analysis disclosed in its FY2025 annual report.
16Source: Neiman Marcus Group source. Neiman Marcus Group
The top 2%Source: Neiman Marcus Group source of customers generated approximately 40%Source: Neiman Marcus Group source of sales, spent over $25,000Source: Neiman Marcus Group source annually, made 25Source: Neiman Marcus Group source+ purchases yearly and had 90%Source: Neiman Marcus Group source retention.
Top customers as a share of all group customers; spending, purchases and retention describe that top group. FY2022 ended July 31, 2022.
Observational sales concentration. Wealth and purchasing power can contribute; emotional fandom and marketing effects are unmeasured. Source
Company customer-segment analysis reported with its FY2022 results.
17Source: Farfetch source. Farfetch
Farfetch reported that its top 1%Source: Farfetch source of customers represented 27%Source: Farfetch source of revenue.
Farfetch's highest-value customer group, discussed alongside its Private Client program. FY2019.
Historical result; the source calls the measure revenue. It does not establish current performance, causality or fandom. Source
Company customer concentration disclosure in its FY2019 annual report.
18Source: Luxury industry / Bain-Altagamma. Luxury customers | Bain-Altagamma
Bain estimates that very important clients, just over 2%Source: Luxury industry / Bain-Altagamma of luxury customers, accounted for 45%Source: Luxury industry / Bain-Altagamma of global luxury purchases in 2024.
Very important clients within Bain's personal-luxury customer analysis. 2024 estimates; published 2025-01-17.
Estimated spending concentration, not measured advocacy. Bain's customer and market definitions differ from BCG's. Source
Market estimates combining company results, macroeconomic data and over 100 expert interviews; observatory covers 280+ luxury companies and brands.
19Source: Luxury industry / BCG-Altagamma. Luxury customers | BCG-Altagamma
Consumers spending over EUR50,000 annually represented 0.1%Source: Luxury industry / BCG-Altagamma of luxury customers and over 23%Source: Luxury industry / BCG-Altagamma of 2024 luxury spending, excluding mobility and wellness/longevity, according to BCG.
Top-tier luxury consumers spending over EUR50,000 annually, using BCG's market definition. 2024 model; report July 2025.
Spending concentration does not establish fandom or advocacy. Customer tiers and market scope differ from Bain's. Source
Market analysis using a 7,000-person survey, 1,000 in-depth top-client surveys, interviews and the Altrata-Wealth-X database.
20Source: Costco source. Costco
Executive memberships numbered 42.3 million out of 84.1 million paid memberships; Executive members accounted for 75.6%Source: Costco source of sales.
Executive memberships versus all paid memberships, not total cardholders. FY2026 Q4 highlights.
Executive memberships are just over half of paid memberships. Counts are a snapshot; the self-selected tier does not establish emotional fandom. Source
Company membership counts and sales penetration disclosed in its FY2026 Q4 investor supplement.
21Source: Target source. Target
Active Target Circle members spent three times as much on average as nonmembers; Circle 360Source: Target source subscribers spent eight times as much.
Active Circle members and Circle 360Source: Target source subscribers, each compared with nonmembers. FY2024 report.
Customer shares, sample sizes and observation window are undisclosed. Self-selected membership does not establish a causal spending lift. Source
Company comparison of customer spending reported in its FY2024 annual-report CEO letter.
22Source: Nordstrom source. Nordstrom
Nordstrom's 10Source: Nordstrom source+ million active loyalty members spent four times as much and shopped three times as often as nonmembers.
Active loyalty-program members versus nonmembers. Reported at Nordy Club launch in September 2018; exact measurement window unspecified.
Historical comparison; observation window and total customer count are undisclosed. Membership's causal effect is unmeasured. Source
Company customer-behavior comparison reported in its September 2018 Nordy Club launch announcement.
23Source: Nike source. Nike
Nike digital members spent nearly twice as much per transaction as other Nike consumers.
Digital members versus other Nike consumers; comparison is per transaction. FY2017 Q3 earnings call.
Historical basket value, not annual spending or lifetime value. Membership's causal effect and cohort sizes are undisclosed. Source
Company transaction-value comparison reported on its FY2017 Q3 earnings call.
24Source: Adidas source. Adidas
Adidas reported that members' consumer lifetime value was more than twice that of nonmembers.
Membership-program members versus nonmembers, using company-calculated lifetime value. FY2021 reporting; LTV model horizon undisclosed.
The lifetime-value formula and model horizon are undisclosed. Association does not establish membership's causal impact. Source
Company lifetime-value comparison disclosed in its FY2021 annual report.
25Source: Williams-Sonoma source. Williams-Sonoma
Cross-brand shoppers were 30%Source: Williams-Sonoma source of customers and spent four times as much as single-brand shoppers. The Key members spent three times as much as nonmembers and purchased twice as frequently.
Cross-brand versus single-brand shoppers; separately, The Key members versus nonmembers. The Key had 10.2 million members. Investor presentation June 2020; exact measurement window undisclosed.
Matching measurement windows are unconfirmed, so no revenue share should be derived. Both comparisons describe one company. Source
Company customer-segment spending and purchase-frequency comparisons presented to investors in June 2020.
26Source: Gap Inc. source. Gap Inc.
Gap's active loyalty members spent twice as much annually, were three times as likely to shop across channels and three times as likely to shop multiple brands.
40Source: Gap Inc. source+ million loyalty members purchasing within 12 months, including credit-card holders. Rolling 12 months through October 2022.
The slide implies a nonmember comparator without separately defining it. Observational differences do not establish program causality. Source
Company loyalty-cohort comparisons in its FY2022 Q3 presentation, covering the 12 months through October 2022.
27Source: Ulta Beauty source. Ulta Beauty
In FY2025, 19%Source: Ulta Beauty source of US loyalty members shopped in stores and digitally. Historically, customers using both channels spent over three times as much as store-only customers.
Channel use among US loyalty members; spending comparison uses multichannel versus store-only customers. FY2025 ended January 31, 2026 for cohort share; historic spending comparison.
The share and spending comparison do not explicitly cover the same period. They cannot be combined into a revenue share. Source
Company channel-use and historical spending comparisons disclosed in its FY2025 annual report.
28Source: Bath & Body Works source. Bath & Body Works
In four loyalty-pilot markets, members spent approximately 30%Source: Bath & Body Works source more than nonmembers.
Loyalty members versus nonmembers in four pilot markets. Four-market loyalty pilot reported July 2021; exact dates unspecified.
Historical pilot without a disclosed randomized design, sample size or observation window. The result does not establish current nationwide performance. Source
Company pilot-market customer comparison reported at its July 2021 investor meeting.
29Source: Nielsen: The Making of a Multicultural Super Consumer. Consumer goods categories
Nielsen reports that the top 10%Source: Nielsen: The Making of a Multicultural Super Consumer of category households can account for at least 30%Source: Nielsen: The Making of a Multicultural Super Consumer of sales, 40%Source: Nielsen: The Making of a Multicultural Super Consumer of growth and 50%Source: Nielsen: The Making of a Multicultural Super Consumer of profits.
The highest-buying 10%Source: Nielsen: The Making of a Multicultural Super Consumer of households in a product category. March 2015.
A potential pattern, not a universal ratio. Detailed category tables and profit calculations are not published in the summary. Source
Nielsen summary of category research, discussing 15 studied categories.
Entertainment and IP: stronger fans buy across more occasions
These comparisons support a relationship between fan intensity and buying behavior. They do not measure the share of Sanrio, Chiikawa or Marvel company revenue generated by top fans.
30Source: Neo Marketing. Japanese character fans
Among female character fans aged 20-29, 7.9%Source: Neo Marketing reported cumulative spending of JPY100,000+ and 39.7%Source: Neo Marketing under JPY1,000. Across all sampled character fans, 43.9%Source: Neo Marketing reported under JPY1,000.
1,000Source: Neo Marketing Japanese adults aged 20Source: Neo Marketing+ who liked famous characters; women's age-20-29 subgroup size undisclosed. Survey June 4–6Source: Neo Marketing, 2025; approximate cumulative spending to date on respondents' favorite characters.
Cumulative periods vary by respondent. Spending bands cannot establish average spending, lifetime value or company revenue shares. Source
Neo Marketing survey comparing self-reported cumulative spending bands by age and gender.
31Source: Morning Consult National Tracking Poll 2111133, table MCEN1_5, printed page 32 (PDF page index 31). Marvel comics fans
69%Source: Morning Consult National Tracking Poll 2111133, table MCEN1_5, printed page 32 (PDF page index 31) of avid Marvel comics fans reported buying comic memorabilia or collectibles at some frequency, compared with 39%Source: Morning Consult National Tracking Poll 2111133, table MCEN1_5, printed page 32 (PDF page index 31) of casual fans.
US adults; Marvel-comics subgroups included 440Source: Morning Consult National Tracking Poll 2111133, table MCEN1_5, printed page 32 (PDF page index 31) avid and 855Source: Morning Consult National Tracking Poll 2111133, table MCEN1_5, printed page 32 (PDF page index 31) casual fans within a 2,200Source: Morning Consult National Tracking Poll 2111133, table MCEN1_5, printed page 32 (PDF page index 31)-adult survey. Survey November 19-22, 2021; results published December 2021.
Purchase frequency, not transaction records, spending amounts, lifetime value or share of Marvel revenue. Source
Morning Consult survey comparing self-reported purchase frequency across fandom-intensity groups.
32Source: Fandom/comScore, The Power of the Fan, issuer press release. Film fans | Fandom/comScore
Heavy movie fans spent 40%Source: Fandom/comScore, The Power of the Fan, issuer press release more on films than light movie fans and were 2.2 times as likely to watch a film on opening weekend.
Heavy movie fans watched 9Source: Fandom/comScore, The Power of the Fan, issuer press release+ hours weekly; subgroup sizes were undisclosed. 2017 publication.
Observational comparison; subgroup sizes undisclosed. Same Fandom/comScore study. Source
Shared survey of 5,000+ people and separate 250,000-person behavioral panel.
33Source: Fandom/comScore, The Power of the Fan, issuer release. TV fans | Fandom/comScore
Heavy TV fans spent 50%Source: Fandom/comScore, The Power of the Fan, issuer release more on television than light TV fans.
Heavy TV fans watched 20Source: Fandom/comScore, The Power of the Fan, issuer release+ hours weekly; subgroup sizes were undisclosed. 2017 publication.
Observational comparison; subgroup sizes undisclosed. Same Fandom/comScore study. Source
Shared survey of 5,000+ people and separate 250,000-person behavioral panel.
34Source: Deloitte, Loyalty scoreboard: exploring fan engagement, pages 1–2. US sports fans | Deloitte
Self-described sports fanatics reported six times the annual spending of casual fans.
Approximately 4,000Source: Deloitte, Loyalty scoreboard: exploring fan engagement, pages 1–2 US adult sports fans, generating 9,159Source: Deloitte, Loyalty scoreboard: exploring fan engagement, pages 1–2 league-level responses across five major leagues. Survey April 2015; report copyright 2015.
Historical self-report. League responses are not unique people, and the cohort's share of total revenue is unknown. Source
April 2015 survey; each participant answered for up to three leagues using self-identified fan affinity.
35Source: YouGov, Female MLB superfans buy merch more frequently than their male counterparts. MLB fans | YouGov
20%Source: YouGov, Female MLB superfans buy merch more frequently than their male counterparts of MLB fans bought merchandise every season. Among very-interested fans, the rate was 33%Source: YouGov, Female MLB superfans buy merch more frequently than their male counterparts for men and 40%Source: YouGov, Female MLB superfans buy merch more frequently than their male counterparts for women.
774 MLB fans within a survey of 2,000Source: YouGov, Female MLB superfans buy merch more frequently than their male counterparts US adults. Survey February 29–March 1Source: YouGov, Female MLB superfans buy merch more frequently than their male counterparts, 2024; published April 11, 2024.
The all-fan comparison includes superfans. Gender-specific rates need weights to combine; no spending-share result is reported. Source
Online survey weighted by demographics, politics and region; superfans defined as very interested in MLB.
36Source: Farshore/HarperCollins Children's Books Annual Review of Children's Reading for Pleasure, page 8. UK children's-book buyers
Heavy buyers were 5.6%Source: Farshore/HarperCollins Children's Books Annual Review of Children's Reading for Pleasure, page 8 of UK children's-book buyers and bought 24.1%Source: Farshore/HarperCollins Children's Books Annual Review of Children's Reading for Pleasure, page 8 of units. Medium and heavy buyers together were 26.6%Source: Farshore/HarperCollins Children's Books Annual Review of Children's Reading for Pleasure, page 8 of buyers and bought 62.1%Source: Farshore/HarperCollins Children's Books Annual Review of Children's Reading for Pleasure, page 8 of units.
Estimated 14.6 million UK children's-book buyers in 2023; heavy buyers bought 16Source: Farshore/HarperCollins Children's Books Annual Review of Children's Reading for Pleasure, page 8+ books annually. 2023 purchasing; report April 2024.
Units, not revenue. Purchase volume defines the groups; buying children's books does not itself establish character fandom. Source
Nielsen buyer segmentation: light 1-5 books, medium 6-15, heavy 16+; combined shares calculated from published categories.
37Source: Motion Picture Association, THEME Report 2019, executive summary and page 27. US and Canadian cinemagoers
Frequent moviegoers were 11%Source: Motion Picture Association, THEME Report 2019, executive summary and page 27 of the US/Canada population aged 2Source: Motion Picture Association, THEME Report 2019, executive summary and page 27+ and purchased 47%Source: Motion Picture Association, THEME Report 2019, executive summary and page 27 of cinema tickets in 2019.
US/Canada population aged 2Source: Motion Picture Association, THEME Report 2019, executive summary and page 27+; frequent moviegoers attended at least monthly. 2019 attendance; survey January 3–29Source: Motion Picture Association, THEME Report 2019, executive summary and page 27, 2020; published March 2020.
The population denominator includes noncustomers. Ticket share is not revenue share; the underlying survey was US-based. Source
ENGINE online survey of 8,032 US adults; adults also reported children's attendance, supporting MPA's US/Canada estimates.
Consumer services: frequent customers have different economics
These are useful examples of repeat buying and customer value. Utility, convenience and subscription benefits can explain the difference without emotional fandom.
38Source: consumer-ai-yipit-2026. US consumer AI customers
The top 1%Source: consumer-ai-yipit-2026 of observed payers generated 19.5%Source: consumer-ai-yipit-2026 of spending, versus 16.6%Source: consumer-ai-yipit-2026 for the bottom half. The top 10%Source: consumer-ai-yipit-2026 generated roughly half. Top-1%Source: consumer-ai-yipit-2026 monthly spending averaged $903Source: consumer-ai-yipit-2026; the median payer spent $25Source: consumer-ai-yipit-2026.
US consumer-card AI spenders observed in YipitData panels, across vendors. August 2026; a16z publication October 5, 2026..
Panel size is undisclosed and purchases may include work tools. The result does not describe every AI app or establish fandom. Source
a16z analysis of YipitData consumer-card and e-receipt panels for August 2026.
39Source: OnlyFans / OnlyTraffic sample. OnlyFans | OnlyTraffic sample
In OnlyTraffic’s acquired-fan sample, 100Source: OnlyFans / OnlyTraffic sample of one million fan subscriptions accounted for 20.2%Source: OnlyFans / OnlyTraffic sample of spending.
100Source: OnlyFans / OnlyTraffic sample of one million fan subscriptions acquired through OnlyTraffic; unique-person deduplication undisclosed. Provider analysis · updated October 2026.
A vendor sample, not OnlyFans-wide results. Repeated subscriptions may not be unique people; no observation window or independent audit. Source
Vendor analysis of its own acquired-fan subscriptions; sample window and unique-person deduplication not disclosed.
40Source: Uber. Uber
Customers using both Mobility and Delivery generated three times the gross bookings of customers using one business, with 35%Source: Uber higher retention.
Customers using both ride-hailing and delivery versus single-business customers. Q2 2025 earnings call.
Observation window and cohort sizes are undisclosed. Gross bookings are not revenue; service use does not establish fandom or causality. Source
Company comparison of customer cohorts, reported by its CEO on the Q2 2025 earnings call.
41Source: Starbucks China source. Starbucks China
Members using retail, delivery and ecommerce spent ten times as much as members visiting retail stores only.
China members using all three channels versus retail-store-only members. Investor Day 2022; exact spend measurement window undisclosed.
China-specific observational comparison. Cohort sizes and spending window are undisclosed; adding channels is not proven to cause the difference. Source
Company customer-channel spending comparison presented at its 2022 Investor Day.
42Source: Paytronix: Loyalty Gets Personal. Restaurant and convenience-store loyalty
The top 10%Source: Paytronix: Loyalty Gets Personal of loyalty members accounted for more than 40%Source: Paytronix: Loyalty Gets Personal of loyalty visits and about half of spending in Paytronix's analysis.
Loyalty members in Paytronix's restaurant and convenience-store customer database. 2023 report; database window January 2020-June 2023; summary April 2024.
Loyalty-program spending, not all restaurant revenue. Detailed percentile aggregation and spending denominator are undisclosed. Source
Provider analysis of loyalty transactions, summarized from its 2023 report.
43Source: Sweetgreen Q4 2025 earnings-call transcript. Sweetgreen
Loyalty members buying both digitally and in stores visited nearly twice as frequently as digital-only customers.
Members transacting digitally and in stores versus digital-only customers; cohort sizes undisclosed. Q4 2025 earnings call, February 26, 2026; measurement window undisclosed.
Comparison is with digital-only customers, not all nonmembers. Customer selection may explain the difference; adding channels is not shown to cause higher frequency. Source
CEO Jonathan Neman's company-results statement; full earnings-call transcript hosted by The Motley Fool.
44Source: DoorDash: How DashPass members make the most of their local neighborhood. DoorDash
Almost one in eight DashPass members ordered from two different businesses at least twice in a month, versus almost one in sixteen nonmembers. Members' orders were also 10%Source: DoorDash: How DashPass members make the most of their local neighborhood larger.
US DashPass members versus nonmembers; sample counts undisclosed. June 2023; company analysis published October 3, 2023.
Paid membership is self-selected. This comparison does not establish emotional fandom, causality or a share of total revenue. Source
DoorDash analysis of orders placed on its platform.
45Source: Maplebear Inc. S-1/A, Amendment No. 2, September 15, 2023, original filing text mirrored by Fast-EDGAR. Instacart
In June 2023, paying Instacart+ monthly active orderers averaged $461Source: Maplebear Inc. S-1/A, Amendment No. 2, September 15, 2023, original filing text mirrored by Fast-EDGAR across 4.0Source: Maplebear Inc. S-1/A, Amendment No. 2, September 15, 2023, original filing text mirrored by Fast-EDGAR orders, versus $223Source: Maplebear Inc. S-1/A, Amendment No. 2, September 15, 2023, original filing text mirrored by Fast-EDGAR across 2.0Source: Maplebear Inc. S-1/A, Amendment No. 2, September 15, 2023, original filing text mirrored by Fast-EDGAR orders for nonmembers.
Paying Instacart+ customers active in the month versus nonmembers. June 2023; September 15, 2023 IPO filing amendment.
Self-selected membership; no causal effect established. Spending is not Instacart revenue. The separate five-year comparison concerns different cohorts. Source
Company order and membership records disclosed in its IPO filing; original text verified through Fast-EDGAR.
Referrals and contribution: value extends beyond personal spending
Advocacy, referral value and community output are distinct outcomes. The overlap with each business’s highest-spending customers needs to be measured.
46Source: National Research Group, The Fandom Formula, pages 4 and 13. Consumer-brand fans | NRG
Surveyed brand fans were 3.5 times as likely as nonfans to describe themselves as advocates.
12,509Source: National Research Group, The Fandom Formula, pages 4 and 13 US adults aged 18-64; 247 brands, with an average 1,477Source: National Research Group, The Fandom Formula, pages 4 and 13 evaluations per brand. Survey April-May 2023; report July 2023.
Self-described advocacy and willingness, not observed referrals or purchases. The comparison does not identify the highest spenders. Source
Nationally representative online survey of stated fandom and brand attitudes, conducted in April-May 2023.
47Source: Journal of Marketing Research. Customer referrals
Referred customers made 31-57% more referrals than nonreferred customers, conditional on purchase activity.
Referred versus nonreferred customers in the study's field dataset. 2025 journal issue.
This concerns referral origin and subsequent referrals. It does not identify the highest spenders or establish a universal effect. Source
Field-data analysis with purchase-activity controls; preregistered lab experiments replicate the referral effect and a field experiment tests a reminder.
48Source: Schmitt, Skiera & Van den Bulte: Referral Programs and Customer Value. German bank customers
Referred customers were at least 16%Source: Schmitt, Skiera & Van den Bulte: Referral Programs and Customer Value more valuable than comparable nonreferred customers and had higher retention.
Approximately 10,000 bank customers, compared by referral status, demographics and acquisition timing. Almost three years of customer records; Journal of Marketing, January 2011.
Referral-acquisition comparison, not a superfan segment. The margin advantage declined with tenure and varied by customer group. Source
Longitudinal analysis of customer profitability and retention over almost three years.
49Source: Pew: Behaviors and Attitudes of US Adults on Twitter. Twitter
The most active 25%Source: Pew: Behaviors and Attitudes of US Adults on Twitter of sampled US adult Twitter users produced 97%Source: Pew: Behaviors and Attitudes of US Adults on Twitter of their tweets.
Sampled US adult accounts ranked by tweet volume, including retweets, replies and quote tweets. Tweets June 12-September 12Source: Pew: Behaviors and Attitudes of US Adults on Twitter, 2021; published November 2021.
Historical content production, not revenue or positive advocacy. The result is specific to the sampled US adult population. Source
Pew survey of 2,548 US adult Twitter users, linked to activity from consenting participants' accounts.
50Source: Priedhorsky et al.: Creating, Destroying, and Restoring Value in Wikipedia. English Wikipedia
The top 10%Source: Priedhorsky et al.: Creating, Destroying, and Restoring Value in Wikipedia of editors by edit count contributed 86%Source: Priedhorsky et al.: Creating, Destroying, and Restoring Value in Wikipedia of measured persistent word views.
English Wikipedia editors; surviving words weighted by estimated readership. Historical data through 2006; GROUP 2007 paper.
Historical content-exposure measure, not article count, revenue or a quality rating. Bot contributions require the paper's methodological context. Source
Researchers reconstructed text authorship from edit histories and estimated readers' exposure using page-view data.
Use the strongest cases to lead the website
Start with Spotify, eBay, Etsy, Kongregate, AppsFlyer, Eventbrite, Neiman Marcus and NRG. Together they cover spending, repeat behavior and advocacy. Put the exact denominator and date on each card; keep the broader collection available as research depth.
Use the next partner’s own data to identify high-value cohorts by repeat purchase, retention, referrals and participation. Then test whether HIRO’s content reaches more people like them and changes a useful customer action. This connects the research to the offer.
The remaining questions are specific
Sanrio, Chiikawa and Hatsune Miku: no verified public customer-level share of total spending emerged from this pass. Character-fan spending brackets and Sanrio’s CRM examples add context, but do not supply that missing number.
Dota, CS2 and guild leadership: Steam playtime and broader game-payer studies support concentration. They do not establish a Dota/CS2 spending split or that high spenders generally lead communities.
The headline: “a minority creates a majority of revenue” fits selected cases, not the whole collection. “Hyperfan” should describe commitment and behavior, not automatically every premium subscriber or high spender. The next useful evidence is a client cohort where purchasing, return behavior and advocacy can be observed together.
Sources
- Spotify for Artists: Super Listeners
Spotify analysis of listening, ticket sales and sharing; averages across artists.
- Nielsen: Turn It Up
Consumer survey segmentation, including a 1,000-person US ePanel and separate PledgeMusic and SXSW samples.
- Luminate: Why Are Super Fans So Valuable?
Luminate consumer survey; 19% of US music listeners met its superfan definition.
- Eventbrite/MusicWatch; issuer release reproduced by National Outdoor Events Association; primary Eventbrite North American analysis
Survey clustering based on spending, attendance frequency, influence and repeat attendance.
- The Broadway League, The Demographics of the Broadway Audience 2018–2019
Audience survey weighted to paid attendance; 17,400 questionnaires distributed with a 52% return rate.
- kongregate-2015
First-party platform purchase analysis and an anonymized game's session comparison, presented at GDC 2015.
- gala-2021
Company payment records and percentile tables disclosed in its December 2022 IPO prospectus.
- appsflyer-2024
Anonymized provider analytics; the overall report covers 15,000 gaming apps meeting its monthly acquisition threshold.
- swrve-2016
Aggregated transaction analytics from Swrve clients; the report describes tens of millions of users and fraud filtering.
- applifier-2014
Survey cross-tabulation of self-reported spending, gaming hours and social behavior, presented at GDC 2014.
- Fandom/comScore, The Power of the Fan, issuer press release
Shared survey of 5,000+ people and separate 250,000-person behavioral panel.
- steam-2013
Researchers enumerated accounts through the public Steam API and analyzed recorded cumulative playtime.
- eBay
Manual transcription of eBay’s published 19m enthusiast buyers, 147m total buyers and 71% GMV share. SQLite calculates the buyer ratio; no access to an eBay customer database.
SQL query
-- Manually transcribed company disclosures, not access to eBay's databases. -- Source: eBay Investor Day 2022 transcript, year-end 2021 buyer data. WITH disclosed_values AS ( SELECT 19.0 AS enthusiast_buyers_millions, 147.0 AS all_buyers_millions, 0.71 AS enthusiast_gmv_share ) SELECT 'Share of buyers' AS measure, enthusiast_buyers_millions / all_buyers_millions AS share, '19m enthusiast buyers / 147m buyers' AS definition, 'Year-end 2021' AS period FROM disclosed_values UNION ALL SELECT 'Share of merchandise value', enthusiast_gmv_share, '71% of GMV, as disclosed', 'Year-end 2021' FROM disclosed_values; - Etsy
Company transaction records segmented by spending and purchase frequency, disclosed in its 2025 annual report.
- Mytheresa source
Company customer-program and merchandise-value analysis disclosed in its FY2025 annual report.
- Neiman Marcus Group source
Company customer-segment analysis reported with its FY2022 results.
- Farfetch source
Company customer concentration disclosure in its FY2019 annual report.
- Luxury industry / Bain-Altagamma
Market estimates combining company results, macroeconomic data and over 100 expert interviews; observatory covers 280+ luxury companies and brands.
- Luxury industry / BCG-Altagamma
Market analysis using a 7,000-person survey, 1,000 in-depth top-client surveys, interviews and the Altrata-Wealth-X database.
- Costco source
Company membership counts and sales penetration disclosed in its FY2026 Q4 investor supplement.
- Target source
Company comparison of customer spending reported in its FY2024 annual-report CEO letter.
- Nordstrom source
Company customer-behavior comparison reported in its September 2018 Nordy Club launch announcement.
- Nike source
Company transaction-value comparison reported on its FY2017 Q3 earnings call.
- Adidas source
Company lifetime-value comparison disclosed in its FY2021 annual report.
- Williams-Sonoma source
Company customer-segment spending and purchase-frequency comparisons presented to investors in June 2020.
- Gap Inc. source
Company loyalty-cohort comparisons in its FY2022 Q3 presentation, covering the 12 months through October 2022.
- Ulta Beauty source
Company channel-use and historical spending comparisons disclosed in its FY2025 annual report.
- Bath & Body Works source
Company pilot-market customer comparison reported at its July 2021 investor meeting.
- Nielsen: The Making of a Multicultural Super Consumer
Nielsen summary of category research, discussing 15 studied categories.
- Neo Marketing
Neo Marketing survey comparing self-reported cumulative spending bands by age and gender.
- Morning Consult National Tracking Poll 2111133, table MCEN1_5, printed page 32 (PDF page index 31)
Morning Consult survey comparing self-reported purchase frequency across fandom-intensity groups.
- Fandom/comScore, The Power of the Fan, issuer press release
Shared survey of 5,000+ people and separate 250,000-person behavioral panel.
- Fandom/comScore, The Power of the Fan, issuer release
Shared survey of 5,000+ people and separate 250,000-person behavioral panel.
- Deloitte, Loyalty scoreboard: exploring fan engagement, pages 1–2
April 2015 survey; each participant answered for up to three leagues using self-identified fan affinity.
- YouGov, Female MLB superfans buy merch more frequently than their male counterparts
Online survey weighted by demographics, politics and region; superfans defined as very interested in MLB.
- Farshore/HarperCollins Children's Books Annual Review of Children's Reading for Pleasure, page 8
Nielsen buyer segmentation: light 1-5 books, medium 6-15, heavy 16+; combined shares calculated from published categories.
- Motion Picture Association, THEME Report 2019, executive summary and page 27
ENGINE online survey of 8,032 US adults; adults also reported children's attendance, supporting MPA's US/Canada estimates.
- consumer-ai-yipit-2026
a16z analysis of YipitData consumer-card and e-receipt panels for August 2026.
- OnlyFans / OnlyTraffic sample
Vendor analysis of its own acquired-fan subscriptions; sample window and unique-person deduplication not disclosed.
- Uber
Company comparison of customer cohorts, reported by its CEO on the Q2 2025 earnings call.
- Starbucks China source
Company customer-channel spending comparison presented at its 2022 Investor Day.
- Paytronix: Loyalty Gets Personal
Provider analysis of loyalty transactions, summarized from its 2023 report.
- Sweetgreen Q4 2025 earnings-call transcript
CEO Jonathan Neman's company-results statement; full earnings-call transcript hosted by The Motley Fool.
- DoorDash: How DashPass members make the most of their local neighborhood
DoorDash analysis of orders placed on its platform.
- Maplebear Inc. S-1/A, Amendment No. 2, September 15, 2023, original filing text mirrored by Fast-EDGAR
Company order and membership records disclosed in its IPO filing; original text verified through Fast-EDGAR.
- National Research Group, The Fandom Formula, pages 4 and 13
Nationally representative online survey of stated fandom and brand attitudes, conducted in April-May 2023.
- Journal of Marketing Research
Field-data analysis with purchase-activity controls; preregistered lab experiments replicate the referral effect and a field experiment tests a reminder.
- Schmitt, Skiera & Van den Bulte: Referral Programs and Customer Value
Longitudinal analysis of customer profitability and retention over almost three years.
- Pew: Behaviors and Attitudes of US Adults on Twitter
Pew survey of 2,548 US adult Twitter users, linked to activity from consenting participants' accounts.
- Priedhorsky et al.: Creating, Destroying, and Restoring Value in Wikipedia
Researchers reconstructed text authorship from edit histories and estimated readers' exposure using page-view data.
- Kevin Kelly: 1,000 True Fans
Conceptual essay, originally 2008; current page contains an updated version and links the original. An illustrative business model, not an empirical concentration study.
- Li Jin / a16z: 1,000 True Fans? Try 100
February 6, 2020 conceptual essay. Higher value per fan through differentiated paid offers, community, access and outcomes; not a general measured spending distribution.